Okay I have received Apple's final response on the matter, before I go into detail. I have a great way to make <dr evil voice>"1 Million Dollars!"</dr evil voice> on the iTunes AppStore.
Create a "Fart-Type" application, harvest all the mobile phone numbers you can. Re-sell the information and profit! Apple's response? "Apple is not responsible for Third Party Products", wow, just wow.. really Apple?
Here is Apple's 6th and final response on the matter:
"Hi (Name),
So I spoke with a few higher ups regarding the concern and they pointed out a few things I thought you might find informative. From what I understand, as long as it doesn't violate your local laws than its not in violation with Apples SDK agreement. Like with any third party product, it is the developers responsibility to make sure they are following local laws and regulations and not the merchant (iTunes).
For information on Apple's Privacy Policy, you can review the Terms of Sale for the App Store:
I located a section for you that applies to your concern:
"Apple is not responsible for Third Party Products, the content therein, or any warranties or claims that you or any other party may have relating to that Third Party Product or your use of the Third Party Product."
I also thought you might find this informative since you are a developer yourself. We set general guidelines outlined in the SDK agreement. Please review below
Local Laws, User Privacy, Location Services and Mapping:
3.3.7 Applications must comply with all applicable criminal, civil and statutory laws and
regulations, including those in any jurisdictions in which Your Applications may be delivered. In addition, for Applications that use location-based APIs or that collect, transmit, maintain, process, share, disclose or otherwise use a user's personal information or data:
- You and the Application must comply with all applicable privacy and data collection laws and regulations with respect to any collection, transmission, maintenance, processing, use, etc. of the user's location data or personal information by the Application.
- Applications may not be designed or marketed for the purpose of harassing, abusing, stalking, threatening or otherwise violating the legal rights (such as the rights of privacy and publicity) of others.
- Applications may not perform any functions or link to any content or use any robot, spider, site search or other retrieval application or device to scrape, retrieve or index services provided by Apple or its licensors, or to collect, disseminate or use information about users for any unauthorized purpose. {<--- Such as selling information to telemarketers .--**Note added by agent, (Name)**}
With that said, its not necessary illegal to retrieve information from your iPhone. However it depends on the intended use of how that information is going to be used by the developer and of course your local laws and regulations. If you have any legal questions regarding your local laws and regulations then I would speak with your personal legal counsel.
I hope those details prove helpful.
Warmest Regards,
(Name)
iTunes Store Customer Support Tier 2
Please note: I work Mon-Fri 9:00am-6:00pm (PST)"
Yup, thanks Apple thats as helpful as a bucket on the Titanic. Okay so here is where we are at, we are looking at coming to day 4 of the issue. All the apps by Storm8 are up on the Appstore and Apple will not remove them unless we prove they are "illegal" or "violate the legal rights" of the user.
So once again, it is back to the iPhone community, what can we do about it? If you are sincerely concerned about it, now is the time and the last opportunity to stand up and be heard. Are you going to stand idly by, while Apple allows your mobile phone number be collect by 3rd parties?
I say let people download spyware to their phones and let IT guys (yours truly) make money fixing their mistakes...
ReplyDeleteIt's none different than AT&T's DSL installer service installing a stupid phone home app on your computer.
Currently there is no 'fix' for apps like the above (other than deleting it) because blocking the host that gets the personal info will render the app useless (it's an online game). Of course most people didn't jailbreak so what 'fix' will you propose there?
ReplyDeleteThe big difference for a pc app is that at least there people have the tools to prevent it. The iPhone gives only very limited tools and only for those prepared to jailbreak.
About the letter:
ReplyDeleteThe App Store - Terms and conditions, also has this:
"b. Consent to Use of Data: You agree that Licensor may collect and use technical data and related information, including but not limited to technical information about your device, system and application software, and peripherals, that is gathered periodically to facilitate the provision of software updates, product support and other services to you (if any) related to the Licensed Application. Licensor may use this information, as long as it is in a form that does not personally identify you, to improve its products or to provide services or technologies to you."
"... that does not personally identify you, ..."
hmmm... Dutch law does see phone numbers as info that can personally identify people, AFAIK. No idea about the US.
I should make it clear that I'm a total noob at the legal stuff, so ..yeah :)
oh, also it seems that dutch law wouldn't apply here cause the data is never stored there.
What we really need is some good free legal advice :)
ReplyDeleteHello internets? you listening?
Ahehe thanks Beholder!