I can say from testing PrivaCy is a very well thought out and implemented, currently PrivaCy can be enabled to stop tracking from:
- pinchmedia
- Flurry
- Medialets
- Mobclix
It is worth mentioning that PrivaCy does not come enabled by default, you must manually enable/disable the services.
Now that PrivaCy is out, we are safe right? It's not really that simple.
Saurik's PrivaCy is great in that it will cover a good number of iPhone apps, it's also great that it is easily obtainable by anyone who has jailbroken their iPhone.
But it's important to remember what PrivaCy does and does not cover, lets examine the pinchmedia enabled application, twitterfon.
* App start
- calls videoegg.adbureau.net, reports an iPhone is being used, sends UDID, app name & version
- calls googleads.g.doubleclick.net, sends country, iPhone, app name & version
- calls met.adwhirl.com, sends app ID, iPhone UDID, country
- calls twitter
- calls pagead2.googlesyndication.com
- calls beacon.pinchmedia.com, sends UDID, iPhone firmware, app ID & version, crack & jailbreak status, start & stop times
* App close
The great news is with PrivaCy enabled the pinchmedia call will not occur at all, however much of the same information has already been sent to multiple providers from the same pinchmedia enabled application.
PrivaCy's design is such that it will not interfere with any custom hosts, I would recommend continuing to use a custom hosts file + PrivaCy if you are concerned about 3rd parties collecting data.
Now is not the time to stop putting pressure on this issue, the excuses from the vendors such as "restrictions were placed by apple" are ludicrous and frankly insulting. As are the claims about anonymity, "it's so we can improve our applications" or "analytics tracks anonymous information for benign, useful purpose".
While the lucky jail-broken few have options, do remember the majority of the iPhone/Touch community who do not have that option and are likely not educated as to the possible issues.
Remember "The price of freedom is eternal vigilance". Till next time happy & safe iPhoning =)
Before anyone asks, yes that is a legit iPhone app icon of a Thomas Jefferson famous quotes app =p
ReplyDeleteSo you are saying that while PinchMedia [or others] may not get the phone home, any other host they set to be phoned will?
ReplyDeleteHiya pipersdragon (nice name btw),
ReplyDeleteSure the message here is, just cause a pinchmedia application is blocked doesn't mean other parts of the application aren't doing the exact same thing that we tried to stop pinchmedia from doing.
I tried to pick the best example, that will illustrate the point in the shortest time.
In other words, just cause PrivaCY is out, we can't let our guard down on the issue :)