Friday, July 31, 2009

Pinchmedia: The Anatomy of a Spyware vendor

Recently while analysing Camera Zoom & Twitterfon, both pinchmedia enabled iPhone applications, I realised that it may not be as apparent to casual iPhone users how user tracking/metrics work.

Most of the iPhone applications that I test use pinchmedia to perform thier "user tracking", so I am going to focus on this in some depth and explain exactly how this works behind the scenes on your mobile.

Firstly, lets start with a definition of spyware from Wiki: "Spyware is a type of malware that is installed surreptitiously on personal computers to collect information about users, their computer or browsing habits without their informed consent."

With this definition in mind, lets look at how pinchmedia enabled applications handle your data.

An iPhone developer can simply drop pinchmedia into their application, from the developer's perspective this is quite easy and all that is required is they pass information about their application to the pinchmedia component, from there the pinchmedia component does the rest.

Once an iPhone application is pinchmedia enabled, on every execution of the application the following information is stored in a local SQLlite database:

- iPhone's unique ID
- iPhone Model
- OS Version
- Application version (in this case, camera zoom 1.x)
- If the application is cracked/pirated
- If your iPhone is jailbroken
- time & date you start the application
- time & date you close the application
- your current latitude & longitude
- your gender (if facebook enabled)
- your birth month (if facebook enabled)
- your birth year (if facebook enabled)

As some people seem to find it hard to visualise, I have extracted the SQL database from Camera Zoom stored on my iPhone, the database looks as follows (data was intentionally omitted):

+---------------------------------------------------------+
| Table: beacon |
+----+--------------+--------------+----------+-----------+
| id | time_started | time_stopped | latitude | longitude |
+----+--------------+--------------+----------+-----------+


+------------------------------------------------------------------+
| Table: sub_beacon |
+------+------------------+-------------------+---------+----------------------+-----------------------+
| id | beacon_id | is_session | name | time_started | time_stopped |
+------+------------------+-------------------+---------+----------------------+-----------------------+

+----------------------------------------+
| Table: user |
+----+--------+-------------+------------+
| id | gender | birth_month | birth_year |
+----+--------+-------------+------------+

In this particular database, there was about a dozen rows of data. It is not clear just how much data pinchmedia will store and attempt to send back to its servers however during analysis it was over half a dozen rows.

Once the application has stored the data, it will attempt to send this information back to the pinchmedia servers. In most cases this is done every-time you open & close a pinchmedia enabled application.

Your data is continually tracked, pinchmedia applications do not take just one sample, they will record every use of the application for the life of that application on your phone. When finally you do have a connection, this information is sent automatically from the application.

To clarify, at no point are you told what the pinchmedia enabled application is doing, at no time are you given an option to "opt-out", you have no control over when the data is sent and what data is sent.

When comparing how this pinchmedia applications work, against the definition of "spyware", is a pinchmedia iPhone application spyware?

Absolutely without no doubt, ANY pinchmedia iPhone application is spyware.

Some simple things you can do, to make a difference
Vote with your wallet
- refuse to purchase pinchmedia enabled applications
- return any purchased applications to Apple

Tell someone who cares
- education is key, spread the word about the issue
- the Internet is a small world, spread the word to your iPhone friends

Keep informed, check this blog!
- Cydia repo goes live soon! Keep up to date against spyware
- Check for new articles, we will continue to discuss this issue with iPhone developers

I would hope that this clears the issue about iPhone spyware, shortly I will be implementing a new easy to understand rating system for iPhone applications covered on this blog.

Till next time, spread the word and happy spyware-free iPhoning :)

Pocket Universe ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

Pocket Universe from the iPhone AppStore is currently number 17 on the AppStore paid applications list.

A pretty basic Astronomy utility, has a very un-intuitive interface.

Version tested: 1.7.1 (current as of writing)

No issues at all, there is an astronomy news section, which simply connects to a not-found mobile me page.

No privacy issues or data leaks, but sadly I could not recommend this application, if you are interested in amateur astronomy check out StarMap Pro.

Wednesday, July 29, 2009

Twitterfon ~ A Developer's response

Recently I contacted the developers of the great iPhone application Twitterfon, sadly this application as previously reviewed is indeed a privacy concern. I would however like to thank the developers for taking the time to put together this reply.

"Hello,

You are right that our application does collect certain user data such as device type and usage, albeit anonymously. We believe, however, that what we do is within Apple's standard EULA, which our application (or any applications on app store, unless otherwise specified) is provided under.

( For Apple's standard EULA, please see http://www.apple.com/legal/itunes/appstore/dev/stdeula/ )

Specifically, EULA stipulates as follows:

b. Consent to Use of Data: You agree that Application Provider may collect and use technical data and related information, including but not limited to technical information about Your device, system and application software, and peripherals, that is gathered periodically to facilitate the provision of software updates, product support and other services to You (if any) related to the Licensed Application. Application Provider may use this information, as long as it is in a form that does not personally identify You, to improve its products or to provide services or technologies to You.

Since the way we collect our data is anonymous, we believe our practice is well within what is allowed under this license terms.

Please let me know if you have further questions."

I will continue to discuss this in a polite manner with the developers to further understand their point of view and hopefully at the same time clarifying the community's concerns. I believe their method is not covered in the EULA and will post their reply if it is available.

Remember the best defense against privacy issues is knowledge & education, till next time, happy & safe iPhoning :D

Tuesday, July 28, 2009

Top25 ~ Week of July 27

Time for a brief rundown on this weeks Top 25 AppStore paid applications (3 are still tba).

1 - Flight Control - safe, great game
2 - Camera Zoom - tracks usage, stores unique ID, records if pirated & jailbroken + your current latitude & longitude!!
3 - I Dig It - safe, fun game
4 - Worms - safe, fun, fun
5 - Ragdoll Blast - tracks usage, sends unique ID's
6 - Bejeweled 2 - safe, good twist on a classic
7 - iFitness - safe, good app
8 - 1,001 Ringtones - tba
9 - Flick Fishing - tracks usage, stores unique ID, records if pirated & jailbroken
10 - Doodle Jump - user tracking, reporting
11 - The Secret of Monkey Island - great game! no issues
12 - The Moron Test - tracks usage, stores unique ID, records if pirated & jailbroken
13 - Pocket God - sends some identifiable data
14 - California Gold Rush - tracks usage, stores unique ID, O/S, application version
15 - Tetris - safe, not bad
16 - Camera Flash - tba
17 - MotionX GPS - great app, well worth the purchase
18 - Pocket Universe - tba
19 - ColorSplash - loads news/alerts data
20 - Aussie Rules LIVE - tracks usage, stores unique ID, records if pirated & jailbroken + your current latitude & longitude!!
21 - StoneLoops! of Jurassica - safe, interesting game
22 - Sally's Spa - safe, nice game
23 - WifiTrak - safe, handy utility if you don't Jailbreak
24 - F.A.S.T - deactivates, tracks usage, stores unique ID, records if pirated & jailbroken
25- Tower Bloxx 3D - tracks usage, stores unique ID, O/S, application version

Well a couple of newcomers to the Top 25, as you can see I need some time to finish 3 of the entries above, however already 10 out of the Top 25 this week contain user tracking/spyware.

Imagine if just those 10 dev's behaved more responsibly, the Top 25 would be spyware free! On this topic, I am working on a rather large and in-depth post titled "Pinchmedia: The Anatomy of a Spyware vendor". Till next time, happy & safe iPhoning!

Monday, July 27, 2009

The Secret of Monkey Island ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

The Secret of Monkey Island from the iPhone AppStore is currently number 11 on the AppStore paid applications list.

A fantastic port of the original RPG classic from the 90's.

Version tested: 1.0 (current as of writing)

The dev's did a fantastic job on this iPhone game, a great port with many new modern features. Well worth the price. No data leaks or any unusual traffic were detected.

One iPhone app that doesn't monkey around :)

MotionX GPS ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

Motion X GPS from the iPhone AppStore is currently number 17 on the AppStore paid applications list.

A very full featured GPS application for your iPhone, great iPhone app well worth the price.

Version tested: 6.1 (current as of writing)

This application connects to google and downloads a small data-set from its own servers. All communications are GPS related, there is no unauthorised transmission of data out of your iPhone.

A great app, well worth the price, this is one iPhone utility that wont leave you stranded :)

Sunday, July 26, 2009

Camera Zoom ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App (updated)

Camera Zoom, a previously examined iPhone app has been updated to now include OS3.0 support. It will be interesting to see if this update also improves on the previously raised privacy concerns.

The makers claim "Camera Zoom is now (the) World's Top Paid iPhone App!" & "App of the Week" - The New York Times, lets take a look...

Version tested: 1.1 (current as of writing)

On start-up this camera application makes 3 connection requests, including pinchmedia on start. 2 requests to its home server and on exit it makes another request to pinchmedia attempting again to upload the tracking data.

Really there is no way you could not catagorise this application as spyware, your iPhone unique ID, iPhone model, OS version, if the app is cracked/pirated, your iPhone is jailbroken, when you start & stop the app also finally... your current latitude & longitude. Oh don't forget it phones-home twice too :)

This can be disabled with the following entries :
# Camera Zoom - contacts a 3rd party, phones-home, sends unique identifiable information including your geographic location
127.0.0.1 itunes.kenditech.com
127.0.0.1 www.kenditech.com
127.0.0.1 beacon.pinchmedia.com

So is it an upgrade? From a privacy & security point of view.. absolutely not.

This is one application that has lost sight of the big picture. The beta cydia repo & hosts files will be updated shortly, happy spyware-free iPhoning!

Saturday, July 25, 2009

TwitterFon ~ iPhone AppStore (updated)

TwitterFon has just been updated to Version 2.0, perusing the change-log we can see that one listed improvement is "Less aggressive ad displaying". Lets have a look at the traffic and see if this translates to less 3rd party traffic.

Version tested: 2.0 (current as of writing)

On startup this application makes roughly 10 network requests, however out of these 10 only 3 are twitter related.

Also another troubling item of note the application as we previously examined "phones-home" but this new version not only sends data about your iPhone use to a single 3rd party, no this new "less aggressive" version goes one further and sends information to 5!! different, unique 3rd party trackers!

Of course the application also uses the infamous pinchmedia services, so it records and sends information such as a unique ID, iPhone model, O/S version, if you have jailbroken, etc.

On top of this, the application now uses an additional 3 mobile advertising providers. The following host entries will prevent this behavior:

# TwiterFon - loads lots of ad's, sends wads of identifiable data about you/your iPhone to MANY 3rd parties
127.0.0.1 ads.mobclix.com
127.0.0.1 adbatch.qwapi.com
127.0.0.1 beacon.pinchmedia.com
127.0.0.1 data.mobclix.com
127.0.0.1 event-img.qwapi.com
127.0.0.1 googleads.g.doubleclick.net
127.0.0.1 met.adwhirl.com
127.0.0.1 mm.admob.com
127.0.0.1 mob.adwhirl.com
127.0.0.1 pagead2.googlesyndication.com
127.0.0.1 r.admob.com
127.0.0.1 s3.amazonaws.com
127.0.0.1 s.mobclix.com

I would caution any iPhone user to consider installing the hosts file/updating from the beta-cydia repo before using TwitterFon.

As usual I have updated the cydia-repo & compiled hosts lists, Grab those iPhones and join me on twitter :)

Thursday, July 23, 2009

Cydia Repository ~ Update

Just a quick update, a small group of volunteers are testing the beta-cydia repo now. The hosts modifications (as listed here on the blog) work great, we are just testing a small binary patch system then the repo will be available to the public.

Tuesday, July 21, 2009

iPhone user tracking & analytics ~ A developers perspective

Anyone who frequents this blog will know that its is all about iPhone applications that "phone-home". This could be an application that simply loads non-essential data or more typically these days its applications that send data to 3rd parties for user analytics.

There are numerous issues these analytics, they all occur without user permission, intervention or knowledge, they now store & forward the data till a connection is available, they include information that personally identifies you/your iPhone, serial numbers, software versions and now even your current latitude & longitude.

Worse yet, this is the accepted norm for the majority of the iPhone applications I have examined (see this weeks Top25 apps for details).

Recently I contacted Apple, PinchMedia (the largest mobile analytics group) and one of the application developers for comment.

In opening with the developer, I asked them perhaps a little too aggressively why their application contains what I would constitute as spy-ware.

They politely responded, stating that their application was spy-ware free, "Thanks for your email. Rest assured that we are certainly not spying or tracking users."

Fortunately, the dev's I just happened to pick are passionate about their products. I was able to continue the dialogue.

When I queried the dev's further, stating the method used by Pinchmedia includes a unique ID, model of the iPhone, firmware/OS, if the application is cracked/pirated & if the iPhone is jailbroken they were responsive.

"the privacy concerns did not occur to us until now, but we will certainly update our app description to advise users how and why we use the information."

After some further discussion, I believed it would be beneficial to get the dev's point of view on the matter (hence this post).

"Considering yours & the communities concerns, we will certainly put a bit more attention into where and how we generate our analytics.

Thank you for offering to post our point of view on the blog. Let me get back to you with an appropriate response"

A couple of days later, some great news from the dev's, "Thanks for the previous email, and even moreso for bring pinch media to our attention. We are looking into alternatives and how to move forward or at least make pinch a much less intrusive analytics solution"

It is really refreshing to see a passionate dev team who care about their iPhone apps, they took the feedback from the community and are committed to ensuring the methods they use are improved to address the privacy & security concerns raised by the community.

I would encourage all iPhone users who care about privacy to support active developers like lookoutmobile (they have my continued financial support), while being more aware of just what your iPhone applications do.

Currently I am chasing comment from Apple & Pinchmedia, if any comments are forthcoming rest assured they will be posted here.

Finally if your passionate about iPhone privacy & security spread the word, educate your iPhone friends. Till next time happy & safe iPhoning!

Monday, July 20, 2009

Top25 ~ Week of July 20

Here is a rundown on this weeks Top25 paid AppStore applications. If you have any requests, feel free to post them in the blog comments.

1 - Flight Control - safe, great game
2 - I Dig It - safe, fun game
3 - Worms - safe, fun, fun
4 - Bejeweled 2 - safe, good twist on a classic
5 - The Moron Test - tracks usage, stores unique ID, records if pirated & jailbroken
6 - Flick Fishing - tracks usage, stores unique ID, records if pirated & jailbroken
7 - California Gold Rush - tracks usage, stores unique ID, O/S, application version
8 - iFitness - safe, good app
9 - Sally's Spa - safe, nice game
10 - Tetris - safe, not bad
11 - Aussie Rules LIVE - tracks usage, stores unique ID, records if pirated & jailbroken + your current latitude & longitude!!
12 - ColorSplash - loads news/alerts data
13 - Harbor Master - safe, not bad
14 - StoneLoops! of Jurassica - safe, interesting game
15 - Camera Zoom - tracks usage, stores unique ID, records if pirated & jailbroken + your current latitude & longitude!!
16 - Tower Bloxx 3D - tracks usage, stores unique ID, O/S, application version
17 - Guinness World Records - safe, fun game
18 - Doodle Jump - user tracking, reporting
19 - Fast & Furious - safe, not too bad
20 - WifiTrak - safe, handy utility if you don't Jailbreak
21 - iBeer Updated - tracks usage, phones-home
22 - Assassins Creed - tracks usage, stores unique ID, O/S, application version
24 - Monopoly - safe, awkward port
25 - F.A.S.T - deactivates, tracks usage, stores unique ID, records if pirated & jailbroken

As always, the compiled hosts file is updated as well as some new additions to the beta-cydia repo, go check it out and happy spyware free iPhoning :)

iFitness ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

iFitness from the iPhone AppStore is currently number 8 on the AppStore paid applications list.

A iPhone app to help you track. measure and manage your fitness. Including a large database of training workouts.

Version tested: 9.35 (current as of writing)

This app works well, seems pretty well done. From a "phone-home" perspective, it makes no unusual calls and runs nicely.

This is one app that doesn't need to trim the fat :)

Sunday, July 19, 2009

StoneLoops! of Jurassica ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

StoneLoops! of Jurassica from the iPhone AppStore is currently number 14 on the AppStore paid applications list.

A puzzle/action game where you eliminate boulders of like color to progress the level.

Version tested: 1.0 (current as of writing)

No issues at all with StoneLoops, the game worsk & plays well. At no time does it make any external calls or connection attempts. Good work dev's :)

Guinness World Records ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

Guinness World Records from the iPhone AppStore is currently number 17 on the AppStore paid applications list.

A fun set of mini-games which let you compete for your own world records.

Version tested: 1.0 (current as of writing)

Although this game does contain network components, it does not make any unusal network attempts, connecting manually will enable score sharing.

Is this a new iPhone app record ? Happy iPhoning!

WifiTrak ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

WifiTrak from the iPhone AppStore is currently number 20 on the AppStore paid applications list.

This small utility allows you to scan local Wifi networks, the tool is pretty well rounded with lots of features.

Version tested: 2.6 (current as of writing)

App starts & runs normally, no unusual traffic detected, however opening the help,about page the paid application loads AD's from its server.

# WifiTrak - loads ad's from home server, otherwise works well
127.0.0.1 www.bitrino.com

Monopoly ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

Monopoly from the iPhone AppStore is currently number 24 on the AppStore paid applications list.

Version tested: 2.3 (current as of writing)

No issues at all with Monopoly, works as expected with no unusual network traffic.

Pass go, collect $200 with this iPhone App :)

Friday, July 17, 2009

MobilityWave "Free" Apps

As requested by NintendoToad I examined a handful of the "free" apps put out by MobilityWave.

Blackjack - Tracks user, unique ID, makes up to a dozen network requests
Hangman - Ad's, Ad's Ad's oh and tracks your usage
Lists - Sends way too much info from your phone, including allot of detail about your connection
Poker - Makes a massive 12 connection requests on start, tracks usage, unique id's, etc
TouchTrain - Ahh pinchmedia! again, tracks your usage, sends info about your iPhone, os version, app version, etc
Video Poker - Tracks usage, loads ad's
Word Wrap - tracks unique id, device name, os version, application version & plenty of ads!

Please be aware, each of these "free" applications not only load dozens of ad's they also track and report usage & uniquely identifiable information from your iPhone.

The worst being lists, which additionally sends way too much information, including more detail about your connection, how you connect (wifi/3g) , if your phone is jailbroken, etc.

I have updated the compiled list and the beta-cydia repo to block all the connections from these apps, happy iPhoning.

Thursday, July 16, 2009

Top25 ~ Summary

Okay the Top25 is all done, I realise the list has shifted but in future it will be much easier/quicker to keep it in-line.

Here is a summary of the top 25 AppStore paid applications:
1 - Flight Control - safe, great game
2 - Worms - safe, fun, fun
3 - The Moron Test - tracks usage, stores unique ID, records if pirated & jailbroken
4 - California Gold Rush - tracks usage, stores unique ID, O/S, application version
5 - Toki Tori - safe, interesting game
6 - Bejeweled 2 - safe, good twist on a classic
7 - Harbor Master - safe, not bad
8 - Tower Bloxx 3D - tracks usage, stores unique ID, O/S, application version
9 - Sally's Spa - safe, nice game
10 - Flick Fishing - tracks usage, stores unique ID, records if pirated & jailbroken
11 - I Dig It - safe, fun game
12 - Tetris - safe, not bad
13 - F.A.S.T - deactivates, tracks usage, stores unique ID, records if pirated & jailbroken
14 - ColorSplash - loads news/alerts data
15 - Assassins Creed - tracks usage, stores unique ID, O/S, application version
16 - Hero of Sparta - tracks usage, stores unique ID, O/S, application version
17 - Aussie Rules LIVE - tracks usage, stores unique ID, records if pirated & jailbroken + your current latitude & longitude!!
18 - Fast & Furious - safe, not too bad
19 - Optus Mobile Usage - safe
20 - Doodle Jump - user tracking, reporting
21 - GloBall - safe, pretty fun
22 - Camera Zoom - tracks usage, stores unique ID, records if pirated & jailbroken + your current latitude & longitude!!
23 - iBeer Updated - tracks usage, phones-home
24 - iBomber - safe, a bit of fun
25 - StickWars - tracks usage, stores unique ID

I have updated the compiled hosts lists as well as the beta-cydia repo for those who have access.

Till next time, safe user-tracking & spy free iPhoning! If you have any suggestions or comments feel free to post them.

Flight Control ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

Flight Control from the iPhone AppStore is number 1 on the AppStore paid applications list.

A simple, but incredibly addictive game this app is great value for money and indeed deserves the number 1 spot.

Version tested: 1.4 (current as of writing)

The App works & plays well with no issues of note at all. No unusual data/traffic was detected.

Get ready for takeoff, happy iPhoning !

Worms ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

Worms from the iPhone AppStore is number 2 on the AppStore paid applications list.

A great port of the multi-platform classic, quite fun as always.

Version tested: 1.0 (current as of writing)

This recent entry to the AppStore works well with no issue and best of all doesn't phone-home.

The Moron Test ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

The Moron Test from the iPhone AppStore is number 3 on the AppStore paid applications list.

Tip from fusen@hackulous :)

Version tested: 1.2 (current as of writing)

This application is really nothing more than a an excuse for user information tracking. At start the application sends uniquely identifying information to a 3rd party about your iPhone, the OS, serial & versions, if

This can be disabled with the following entry which has been tested not to interfere with the application:

# The Moron Test - contacts a 3rd party, sends unique ID, if pirated & your phone is jailbroken
127.0.0.1 beacon.pinchmedia.com

This app sure failed the Moron test, I just feel bad for all those poor iPhone users who have this.

California Gold Rush ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

California Gold Rush from the iPhone AppStore is number 4 on the AppStore paid applications list.

A puzzle/strategy game.

Version tested: 1.0.1 (current as of writing)

At start, like most of the apps I have looked at from this developer, it sends your information to a 3rd party, this as usual includes a unique id, os, phone model, etc.

This can be disabled with the following entry which has been tested not to interfere with the application:

# California Gold Rush - sends data to a 3rd party, including iPhone OS, serials, versions, etc
127.0.0.1 data.flurry.com

Looks like this iPhone app turned out to be fools gold =)

Toki Tori ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

Toki Tori from the iPhone AppStore is number 5 (the sales chart has shifted since I started) on the AppStore paid applications list.

A platform/puzzle game guide Toki Tori to gather the eggs.

Version tested: 1.2 (current as of writing)

Another Top25 app with no issues, plays well doesn't try to "phone-home".

This chicken hasn't flown the coop, happy iPhoning !

Wednesday, July 15, 2009

20 apps down, 5 to go!

I have finished going through 20 of the top 25 iPhone apps, now only 5 to go! time permitting I should finish this by tomorrow.

Going forward I will post a weekly summary of the top 25 paid applications. If you have any comments or suggestions feel free to post here.

Bejeweled 2 ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

Bejeweled 2 from the iPhone AppStore is number 6 on the AppStore paid applications list.

A modern spin on the classic Bejeweled game by PopCap the makers of the hit game peggle.

Version tested: 1.1.1 (current as of writing)

No issues at all with this application, works fine, plays well and doesn't send all your private info to strangers.

Tis a nice little gem, happy iPhoning !

Harbor Master ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

Harbor Master from the iPhone AppStore is number 7 on the AppStore paid applications list.

A harbor management simulation, similar to Flight Control but with ships.

Version tested: 1.0 (current as of writing)

This application works normal, includes options to save & post your scores on-line, also includes a privacy policy regarding your information.

I'll look further into the traffic posted back, but at this stage it looks good.

Let's hope its clear sailing, till then happy iPhoning:)

Tower Bloxx 3D ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

Tower Bloxx 3D from the iPhone AppStore is number 8 on the AppStore paid applications list.

A 3D tower building/puzzle game.

Version tested: 1.0.10 (current as of writing)

At start up this application sends information to track your usage to a 3rd party, including details about your iPhone, the OS, model, etc. (confirmed)

This can be disabled with the following entry which has been tested not to interfere with the application:

# Tower Bloxx 3d - sends identifiable data to a 3rd party, including iPhone OS, serials, versions, etc
127.0.0.1 data.flurry.com

Guess this iPhone app, just doesn't stack up! I'll update the beta-repo & compiled list soon.

Sally's Spa ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

Sally's Spa from the iPhone AppStore is number 9 on the AppStore paid applications list.

This game puts you in the shoes of Sally who as the name suggests is building a spa-empire, with a variety of mini-games this makes for a fun addictive treat.

Version tested: 1.3 (current as of writing)

These dev's seemed to have put allot of effort and polish into their game, it works & plays well and best of all, it doesn't phone-home. No unusual traffic, data leaks etc.

Isnt it relaxing ? Happy iPhoning!

Flick Fishing ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

Flick Fishing from the iPhone AppStore is number 10 on the AppStore paid applications list.

An interactive fishing game for the iPhone.

Version tested: 1.3.1 (current as of writing)

This application connects to the iTunes server, pinchmedia, iTunes again, the apps home servers for scoring information, then finally back to pinchmedia.

I'll post back tomorrow with the exact details of what information this sends, it will be especially interesting to see what is being returned to apple.

This can be disabled with the following entry, which will disable the communication but prevent in game scoring, it may (not tested) have an affect on itunes also.

# Flick Fishing - phones home, connects to apple, sends apple information, sends sends unique ids, tracks usage
127.0.0.1 beacon.pinchmedia.com
127.0.0.1 www.freeverse.com

Remember if it smells fishy, it probably is :) -

Update: I removed two lines as it interferes with the AppStore, also the pinchmedia data is what we have come to expect. However this app also sends an encrypted data stream back to Apple :o

I Dig It ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

I Dig It from the iPhone AppStore is number 11 on the AppStore paid applications list.

This iPhone game lets you control a digger, the aim of the game is to get money from mining to save your farm.

Version tested: 1.1 (current as of writing)

Another good example of a well written, well behaved application. This game makes no unusal calls or activity. Using the facebook option does connect only to what would seem the appropriate servers.

Can you dig it ? yes you can :)

Tuesday, July 14, 2009

Tetris ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

Tetris from the iPhone AppStore is number 12 on the AppStore paid applications list.

Version tested: 1.1.87 (current as of writing)

Whew, a break in apps phoning-home for a while, this application functions normally,makes no unusual calls (or any at all).

Thats one piece in the puzzle down :)

F.A.S.T ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

F.A.S.T from the iPhone AppStore is number 13 on the AppStore paid applications list.

A 3D fighter plane arcade/simulation game.

Version tested: 1.5 (current as of writing)

This application phones-home on start and validates the application, sending information allowing the publisher to determine if the game has been pirated. Also this app sends a unique id, the app version, and an app identifier to their server.

The server response seems to indicate the game can be disabled at start-up if the piracy check fails however this seems to be currently unused.

This can be disabled with the following entry, which will disable the communication but prevent score sharing in-game:

# F.A.S.T - phones home 3 to 4 times, checks if app is pirated, sends unique ids, tracks usage
127.0.0.1 ijet.iphone.sgn.com
127.0.0.1 bar.iphone.sgn.com

Happy i-phone-home free gaming :)

ColorSplash ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

ColorSplash from the iPhone AppStore is number 14 on the AppStore paid applications list.

A iPhone utility that lets you colourise/adjust your pictures stored on your iPhone.

Version tested: 1.3 (current as of writing)

This application works well, however on load it retrieves notifcations from its home server.

This can be disabled with the following entry, which has been tested as working:

# ColorSplash - retrieves news/alerts from home server, otherwise behaves
127.0.0.1 www.juxtaposer.info

So many apps to test, so little time. I'll update the compiled list & the beta-cydia repo shortly.

Assassins Creed ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

Assassins Creed from the iPhone AppStore is number 15 on the AppStore paid applications list.

A 3D action/adventure game, based on the console hit. Uses the same engine as Hero of Sparta?

Version tested: 1.1.5 (current as of writing)

Ahh gameloft... why? your games arnt too bad, So far the same as all the other Gameloft games, this iPhone game will send your country, application version a unique ID, the date and the version of the app.

This can be disabled with the following entry, which has been tested as working:

# Assassins Creed - sends identifiable data to its own server, including unique ID's, iPhone OS, serials, versions, etc
127.0.0.1 ingameads.gameloft.com

Hero of Sparta ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

Hero of Sparta from the iPhone AppStore is number 16 on the AppStore paid applications list.

A 3D action/adventure game, it's actually quite well done with good production values.

Version tested: 1.0.6 (current as of writing)

Another Gameloft game which works the same as the previously reviewed Lets Golf! On the application start this iPhone game will send your country, application version a unique ID, the date and the version of the app.

This can be disabled with the following entry, which has been tested as working:

# Hero of Sparta - sends identifiable data to its own server, including unique ID's, iPhone OS, serials, versions, etc
127.0.0.1 ingameads.gameloft.com

Also, for anyone who has noticed the Top25 has shifted a little, i'll finish writing up the apps that I have, almost done!

Monday, July 13, 2009

An apple a day...

Just an update on the whole phone-home issue, I have decided to contact Apple for a response, also I am going to contact a couple of the application developers to get their opinion on this issue.

Update : Aussie Rules LIVE, we have a winner !

I don't usually spend a whole post on an update to a previous post, but we have a winner !

Aussie Rules LIVE, takes the cake, then takes it behind the shed and makes babies, then pimps out the cake for cash, then it really starts to get interesting!

Lets look at a time-line of the application's execution
- Application start
- Downloads latest data from home server
- Downloads updates from home server
- Requests permission to use your location
- Connects securely (via SSL) to Apple's location server
- Then, the application promptly jumps the shark
- Connects to the 3rd party pinchmeadia server, then sends the following information
* Your iPhone ID
* Your iPhone model
* Your iPhone OS version
* Information identifying the application (Aussie Rules LIVE)
* The application version
* If the application is cracked
* If your iPhone is jailbroken
* What time you started the application
* What time you stopped the application
* and finally the cherry on top, your current Latitude and Longitude

Well without seeming alarmist, what can I say ? If this was a PC application it would be classified as a major piece of Spyware, but for some reason this seems the norm on the iPhone?

I would strongly advise all iPhone users to avoid using any & all applications that utilise the pinchmedia services. In fact I think this issue is so serious, it's time to contact apple for comment.

Play it safe guys, happy iPhoning! You can find the compiled hosts list above which will block this application phoning-home.

Aussie Rules LIVE ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

Ausse Rules LIVE from the iPhone AppStore is number 17 on the AppStore paid applications list.

Version tested: 3.0 (current as of writing)

Another one of these lovely pinch media apps, ill dig through the traffic and report the results tomorrow, but you guessed it ! the app phones home, sends unique/private information to 3rd party servers regarding you & your iPhone.

What remains undetermined at this stage is just how much of your privacy and rights they have violated :)

This can be disabled with the following entry :

# Aussie Rules LIVE - contacts a 3rd party, sends identifiable information about you & your mum
127.0.0.1 beacon.pinchmedia.com

The compiled list is updated, as of tomorrow I hope the cydia repo will also be online.

Fast & Furious ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

Fast & Furious from the iPhone AppStore is number 18 on the AppStore paid applications list.

Actually a pretty good racing game which based loosely on the recent movie.

Version tested: 0.3.5 (current as of writing)

This iPhone game behaves nicely, it communicates only when the user initiates a multi-player/online game, there seems to be no excessive traffic at all.

Happy Fast & Furious iPhoning ! I will update the compiled list shortly.

Optus Mobile Usage ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

Optus Mobile Usage from the iPhone AppStore is number 19 on the AppStore paid applications list.

This is an application to check your Optus Mobile usage.

Version tested: 1.4 (current as of writing)

As far as i can see from the traffic, this application only contacts the servers/systems that it is supposed to. However there does seem to be an internal check for jailbreaking/legitimacy.

All, in all, seems to be okay :)

Doodle Jump ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

Doodle Jump from the iPhone AppStore is number 20 on the AppStore paid applications list.

Doodle Jump is jumping/platform (kinda) game where the aim is to see how high you can get

Version tested: 1.3 (current as of writing)

Doodle Jump gets so close... but fails. It even asks you if you want to submit/disable score tracking but then goes ahead and phones-home anyway, heck it will phone home a couple of times just to be sure :)

# Doodle Jump - 1 request @ start, repeats requests every level, phones-home & some basic usage tracking
127.0.0.1 www.limasky.com

Disabling this will likely affect the in-game scoreboard sharing, Happy gaming !

GloBall ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

GloBall from the iPhone AppStore is number 21 on the AppStore paid applications list.

GloBall is a simple yet addictive game where you roll a ball around, collecting blocks while avoiding obstacles.

Version tested: 1.0 (current as of writing)

GloBall works how all the other apps on this list should, yes it has location and other services but it tells/asks you, when you decline to use the online functions the application makes no attempt to connect to their servers.

See how easy it is :)

Sunday, July 12, 2009

Update: Holy invasion of privacy batman!

Okay, just finished going over the traffic from Camera Zoom & StickWars as previously noted both are "Top25" applications.

StickWars, does indeed phone-home with such delightful information such as your iPhone's identity, OS version, application version and then goes one step further by sending status information as to if your phone is jailbroken and the app is cracked.

Camera Zoom, then tries to top this by not only sending most of the information above, but also attempts to send your latitude & longitude to its servers! Which probably explains why this app is busted atm, it's probably due to the introduction of the location services controls/and/or OS3.0.

Happy spyware & location tracking free iPhoning !

Cydia Repository coming soon!

Just a quick post, I am working on beta-testing the Cydia repository for this site right now. It should be working sometime very soon!

Although it will be very simple, If your interested, post some feedback.

Camera Zoom ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

Camera Zoom from the iPhone AppStore is number 22 on the AppStore paid applications list.

Sadly Camera Zoom still needs some work for OS 3.0. but it does start-up.

Version tested: 1.0 (current as of writing)

Yet again, another "budget" application using pinchmedia, on start this application contacts a 3rd party and sends unique identifiable information to a 3rd party. Like StickWars I will go further into this traffic tomorrow.

This can be disabled with the following entry :

# Camera Zoom - contacts a 3rd party, sends identifiable information
127.0.0.1 beacon.pinchmedia.com

Why on earth would an app that provides digital zoom, need to phone-home, not only does it phone-home it sends information that can be used to identify & track the user.

iBeer Updated ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

iBeer Updated from the iPhone AppStore is number 23 on the AppStore paid applications list.

iBeer is a gimmick app that simulates the drinking of mostly beer related fluids.

Version tested: 3.0.5 (current as of writing)

Application phone's-home, then uses google-analytics for usage tracking, to disable add the following entries:

# iBeer Updated - 2 requests, phones-home & tracks usage
127.0.0.1 www.google-analytics.com
127.0.0.1 www.hottrixdownload.com

Mostly harmless, though i will never understand what devs were thinking when they added usage & unauthorised network access to a mobile application.

iBomber ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

iBomber from the iPhone AppStore is number 24 on the AppStore paid applications list.

iBomber is a arcade style bombing game based in the Pacific Ocean in 1943.

Version tested: 1.0 (current as of writing)

Finally, the application works as it should with no unusual or un-warranted traffic :) Go-Play!

StickWars ~ iPhone AppStore, A Top25 App

StickWars from the iPhone AppStore is number 25 on the AppStore paid applications list.

StickWars is a defense based game, where you protect your wall from invading stick characters.

Version tested: 1.5 (1 update behind current)

Off to a good (or bad) start, this application uses pinchmedia to track not only your usage, but also personally identifiable information from your iPhone.

This can be disabled with the following entry :

# StickWars - 2 requests to 3rd party, at start & exit. Sends identifiable information to a 3rd party
127.0.0.1 beacon.pinchmedia.com

I will do some more work on deciphering this traffic tomorrow, but it may include information about the legitimacy of the application as well as other data, be forewarned.

Top 25 AppStore, Paid applications

I will start to work through the top 25 paid applications, it will be interesting to see just how many of these "top" apps phone-home.

QuickOffice~ iPhone AppStore

QuickOffice from the iPhone AppStore, A portable office compatible/document viewer

Version tested: 1.2.0

Firstly, let me say this is a great app, for the most part it is well behaved however every application start-up it "pings" home, while it does not send any unique id's it does send the version info and enough info for usage tracking.

This can be disabled with the following entry, which has been tested as working online help will not function.

# QuickOffice - "Pings" the server every start-up, sends version & tracking info
127.0.0.1 www.quickoffice.com

All updated :) happy iPhoning !

Pocket God ~ iPhone AppStore

Pocket God from the iPhone AppStore, A interactive god simulator/episodic micro-game.

Version tested: Episode 21 (1.20) (current as of writing)

On application launch, the game connects to the openfeint server, sending uniquely identifiable information, including a catalog of your installed applications. This is done on start, automatically without the user launching openfeint from the menu.

This can be disabled with the following entry, which has been tested as working however you will not be able to view the openfeint lobby in game:

# Pocket God - Sends unique identifiers/application information to 3rd party servers on app start & in-game
127.0.0.1 api.openfeint.com

The compiled list has been updated, anyone got any requests ?

StarDefense ~ iPhone AppStore

StarDefense from the iPhone AppStore, Taking tower defense games 3D and into space.

Version tested: 1.3 (current as of writing)

This application works exactly the same as Rolando 2, as the game loads it makes 4-5 request to ngmoco servers followed by the +Plus network servers.

While I see no issue with apps containing community functions, I do object to apps communicating/sending information to thier servers without permission, the app starts communicating even before any of these functions are used.

Again information about you/your iPhone, the application version, etc may be sent to thier servers.

The first two lines disable the app from phoning-home, the last two disable the +Plus network features.

# StarDefense - 5 requests at app load, community functions, phone's home, sends identifiable data, app/version info to servers
127.0.0.1 apps.ngmoco.com
127.0.0.1 config.ngmoco.com
127.0.0.1 app.plusplus.com
127.0.0.1 wordpress.ngmoco.com

I have updated the compiled list, happy iPhoning =)

Saturday, July 11, 2009

Rolando 2 ~ iPhone AppStore

Rolando 2 from the iPhone AppStore, A fun puzzle/platform game for the iPhone

Version tested: 1.0 (current as of writing)

This application uses the +Plus network, despite this the game still phones home even before you invoke any plus functions. Using +Plus will send information that identifies you & the applications you use to a 3rd party. Also Rolando 2 will, even without you using +Plus send identifiable information about you/your iPhone, the application version, etc to their server

The first two lines disable the app from phoning-home, the last two disable the +Plus network features.

# Rolando2 - 3 requests at app load, has community functions, phone's home, sends identifiable data, app/version info to servers
127.0.0.1 apps.ngmoco.com
127.0.0.1 config.ngmoco.com
127.0.0.1 app.plusplus.com
127.0.0.1 wordpress.ngmoco.com

Happy tracking-free iPhone gaming !

Jaadu RDP ~ iPhone AppStore

Jaadu RDP from the iPhone AppStore, Utility connect to a RDP server on the go

Version tested: 2.0.1 (current as of writing)

This application makes around 8 requests, before you even connect to a RDP Server, including version checking, phoning home and multiple usage tracking requests.

This can be disabled with the following entries, which has been tested as working:

# Jaadu RDP - makes 8 requests, phones home, tracks usage, checks for new version
127.0.0.1 www.jugaari.com
127.0.0.1 www.statcounter.com
127.0.0.1 www.google-analytics.com
127.0.0.1 c.statcounter.com

I will update the compiled list shortly :)

TwitterFon ~ iPhone AppStore

TwitterFon from the iPhone AppStore, Lets you update/manage your twitter on the go

Version tested: 1.5.4 (current as of writing)

Twiter traffic seems to work as expected, application contacts ad servers, sending your location and some information to get targeted ad's. Then on exit the application sends unique/identifiable data to a 3rd party

This can be disabled with the following entries, which has been tested as working:

# TwiterFon - loads ad's, also sends identifiable data about you/your iPhone to a 3rd party
127.0.0.1 r.admob.com
127.0.0.1 mm.admob.com
127.0.0.1 s.mobclix.com
127.0.0.1 data.mobclix.com
127.0.0.1 ads.mobclix.com
127.0.0.1 event-img.qwapi.com
127.0.0.1 met.adwhirl.com
127.0.0.1 beacon.pinchmedia.com

I have merged all these into the compiled list.

Friday, July 10, 2009

Perma-banned from www.modmyi.com

Well I guess some people over at http://www.modmyi.com don't like my blog :)

Apologies to any readers at http://www.modmyi.com who may have found this information informative, helpful or even just interesting as I am not going to bother going through all the effort re-registering to post in such an closed minded community.

peace, out!

Thursday, July 9, 2009

Project Hysteria ~ iPhone AppStore

Project Hysteria from the iPhone AppStore, An interactive graphic horror game.

Version tested: 1.2 (current as of writing)

On-start the application downloads the latest news items from its server

This can be disabled with the following entry, which has been tested as working however you will not be able to view the "bulky channel" in game:

# Hysteria Project - downloads RSS feed from server,
127.0.0.1 www.bulkypix.com

This entry has been added into the compiled list :)

Let's Golf! ~ iPhone AppStore

Let's Golf! from the iPhone AppStore, A highly entertaining golf game for the iPhone

Version tested: 1.1.0 (current as of writing)

On-start the application registers remotely, sending such details as your iPhone make, model, OS, country, unique identifiers and the application version. The remote servers kindly respond "Thank you!".

This can be disabled with the following entry, which has been tested as working:

# Let's Golf! - sends identifiable data to its own server, including unique ID's, iPhone OS, serials, versions, etc
127.0.0.1 ingameads.gameloft.com

Compiled list is updated, if anyone has any app's they would like tested, please post in the "Introduction" comments.

Ragdoll Blast ~ iPhone AppStore

Ragdoll Blast from the iPhone AppStore, A great puzzle game involving shooting ragdolls from cannons

Version tested: 1.1 (current as of writing)

Application is a stand-alone game with no unusual activity during gameplay, however every start-up it sends uniquely identifying information about your iPhone, OS, Model, etc to a 3rd party.

This can be disabled with the following entry, which has been tested as working:

# Ragdoll Blast - sends identifiable data to a 3rd party, including iPhone OS, serials, versions, etc
127.0.0.1 data.flurry.com

Compiled list is updated, happy spy-ware free iPhoning !

UPDATE: After re-analysing this traffic, this app may be including information regarding it's legitimacy.

iBlogger ~ iPhone AppStore

iBlogger from the iPhone AppStore, A utility to manage & udpate your blog's from your iPhone

Version tested: 1.07 (current as of writing)

Application works as expected while updating/editing blog entries, however it does send usage tracking information to a 3rd party. This seems to include uniquely identifiable information about your iPhone.

This can be disabled with the following entry, which has been tested as working:

# iBlogger - sends identifiable data to a 3rd party, blog edits work as normal
127.0.0.1 t.medialytics.com

The compiled list has again been updated, happy user-tracking free iPhoning !

SBSettings ~ Cydia

SBSettings from Cydia, Great utility to let you control/toggle services & settings on your iPhone

Version tested: 3.0.1 (current as of writing)

This application is well behaved, it will not attempt to make any calls to ad servers until you select "More" from the menu. Then the application will make 3-4 connections, including phoning home and loading adverts. Continuing to make around 1-2 connections per minute.

This can be disabled with the following entries, which has been tested as working however you will not be able to access advanced features via the "More" button. There is a work around for this, google is your friend :)

# SBSettings - phones home, makes periodical requests
127.0.0.1 extra.thebigboss.org
127.0.0.1 r.admob.com
127.0.0.1 mm.admob.com

I have updated the compiled list to include these changes, happy iPhoning !

iiQuota ~ iPhone AppStore

iiQuota from the iPhone AppStore, A utility to track your Mobile & Internet usage

Version tested: 6.91 (current as of writing)

Application works as expected during the retrieval of the quota related information, however does contain usage tracking calls (seems to attempt 2 connections) which store & track your usage. The data seems to also include uniquely identifiable information about your iPhone.

This can be disabled with the following entry, which has been tested as working:

# iiQuota - 2 connections, sends identifiable data to 3rd party, other functions are fine
127.0.0.1 beacon.pinchmedia.com

As always, the main list has been updated =)

Psx4iPhone ~ Cydia

Psx4iPhone from Cydia, newly updated PSX emulator for the iPhone (works best on the 3GS)

Version tested: 1.0.0 (current as of writing)

This application literally hammers & pounds your connection, in testing on start-up makes a whoppping 12-18 connections. While left at the menu, Psx4iPhone continues to periodically load adverts making roughly 7 connections per minute!

This can be disabled with the following entries, which has been tested as working however you will not be able to access www.zodttd.com.

# PSx4iphone - makes 18 HTTP Requests, then continues to request peridocially
127.0.0.1 www.zodttd.com
127.0.0.1 r.admob.com
127.0.0.1 mm.admob.com

I have updated the compiled list to include these changes, happy iPhoning !

MxTube ~ Cydia

MxTube from Cydia, a youtube video downloader/offline player

Version tested: 1.5c (current as of writing)

Application loads ad's & the front page "Featured" everytime the application starts, on start-up MxTube makes around 8 web calls, including ad-servers, its homepage & google analyitics

This can be disabled with the following entry, which has been tested as working however the "Featured" page will display blank.

# MX Tube - makes 8 HTTP requests, ad servers & google analytics
127.0.0.1 mxtube.iphone.mxweas.com
127.0.0.1 img1.iphone.mxweas.com
127.0.0.1 www.google-analytics.com
127.0.0.1 r.admob.com

I have updated the compiled list to include these changes, happy iPhoning !

Facebook ~ iPhone AppStore

Facebook from the iPhone AppStore

Version tested: 2.5 (current as of writing)

Application works as expected for the most part, but does make "unusual" calls on exit, looks to include an identifier used for usage tracking.

The call at the application exit, returns the very unusual string "Move along now."

This can be disabled with the following entry, which has been tested as working:

# Facebook - makes an "unusual call" on exit
127.0.0.1 0.channel15.facebook.com

I have updated the compiled list, which is now available above.

Wednesday, July 8, 2009

iPhone OS3.0

Well seems a good enough place as any to start, lets run briefly through iPhone OS3.0 for any interesting activity.

Each general application listed below was tested in turn, looking for any unusual activity.

Calendar, Photos, Camera, Stocks, Maps, Weather, Voice Memos, Notes, Clock, Calculator & Compass all worked as expected.

E-mail ~ After testing & re-testing, e-mail does seem periodically connect to your mail server regardless of your push, pull, fetch or any other settings. (this possibly explains part of the battery life issue?)

If this worries you, look at the Cydia tools to switch on/off your Edge/3G/WiFi connections.

iTunes ~ iTunes makes allot of calls, on application start-up alone it makes over 14 requests. Most but not all requests are related to the iTunes store, it does indeed make extra calls to track your usage.

App Store ~ the App Store is very similar to iTunes, on application start-up it makes around 15 requests, again two related to usage tracking.

All in all, both iTunes & the App Store function as expected, they are both heavy traffic applications and should be treated as such.

Finally the e-mail requests have me puzzled, I will do some more testing but at this stage my phone is putting out around one request per minute regardless of the fact I have configured it to sync manually.

Wednesday, July 1, 2009

Thank you for your donation!

Thank you very much for your donation, while I do not mind at all paying for this project. Any contribution will help cover the hosting costs for the repository, furthermore it will be possible even with some humble funds to help support the developers that make the iPhone the exciting platform that it is.

Kind Regards
0th3lo