Recently after reviewing the traffic from TouchKO I thought I would contact the application developers for a response.The dev's were kind enough to respond with their point of view on the matter of the user-metrics/tracking.
I feel one of the key's to addressing and one day resolving the privacy concerns around user metrics is to take the time to listen and understand why the dev teams implement the metrics. As such we should thank the dev's for taking time from development to reply to our concerns.
"Hi -- I'm Matt Mechtley, the programmer of Touch KO. Here's some more detailed information about what data we collect and how we use it:
Blurst:
While Chillingo published Touch KO, it was developed entirely by my brother Adam and I. We made it in our free time, but we both work for indie developer Blurst as our day jobs. Thus Blurst would more correctly be termed the first party (i.e. the developer) rather than a third party. If you want more information about us, you can check out the Blurst about page: http://blurst.com/about/
As noted in the article, stuff we collect via Blurst:
UDID, game ID, date/time, various gameplay data (tracking numbers for achievements, high scores, etc).
PinchMedia:
We use PinchMedia's Pinch Analytics suite to track some of the same information, but in a way that is more easily digestible. We'd prefer not to double up the collected data, but PM already has a lot of useful tools for analyzing the data (nice graphs, etc) that Blurst, as a five person company, does not have the time to recreate. All of the data we collect via PA is available only in aggregate; the individually submitted records aren't available. Note that we may eventually drop this service, as I am not convinced it is giving accurate enough information to be useful.
Stuff we collect through PA:
UDID, OS version, device type, jailbroken status, pirate status, app start/stop times.
How we use this stuff:
Overall, any analytics data we collect is used simply to help us improve the game. Since we're only two people, we need data to help us prioritize what we work on next. Let's say we were considering adding better graphics for 3GS users, but our data indicated only 2% of our users were on 3GS. We would then know that this is probably a bad use of our time. Likewise if our data indicated that only 5% of users were winning the third fight, we'd know that we needed to make it easier.
Regarding UDID, this is our only way to ensure non-duplicate information. It is unique to your device, but there is no way for us (or anyone else, besides maybe Apple) to link it to personally-identifiable information (other than your email address obviously, if you create a Blurst account).
Why we send data for guests:
This is to improve user experience, and again to ensure that we're getting accurate information about how all of our users are playing the game -- not just those who created accounts. If a player is playing as a guest and gets a high score or completes an achievement, we want to give them the opportunity to create an account if they don't have one. Any scores or achievements you get while playing as a guest will automatically be linked to your account if you ever create one.
We were quite careful in our wording on the data warning to state flatly that the Touch KO sends data to the internet -- no ifs or conditions, it always does. However, we're only using that data to help make the game better!
Cheers,
Matt"
I have since responded to the developers to further explain my concerns and look forward to some more correspondence with the team. As for the community, if your concerned get out there, spread the word and raise the profile of this issue.
I'm sorry, but the developer's response reeks of bull-crap to me. They track my UUID, jailbreak status, and pirate status. Too much info to take without my express permission and understanding of what exactly they're taking and why.
ReplyDeleteWhile the explanation of the UUID being the only way to ensure non-duplication of data sounds reasonable on the surface so that your high scores as a guest can be credited to your account, it feels big brother-ish, and ignores the fact that if the player wanted credit to be remembered, they would create an account.
Furthermore, it's absolutely no one's business except my own if I have jailbroken my iPhone. What possible use of that info could they have? To deny tech support if there are issues with the game? Perhaps, but not likely useful information.
The piracy status is legit, but like pissing in the wind. They have the right to protect their intellectual property, but they are violating the privacy of all of their users to go after a small percentage of people that will never pay for the software to begin with. I imagine them disabling the game in some manner if they think you're pirated. That's fair enough, but with a UUID attached, they could permanently ban a device and even share the UUID with other vendors.
devs, keys, cars, cats, houses. PLURAL, hence "s" at the end. cat's whiskers, dog's tail, Mike's coffe. POSSESSIVE, hence "'s" at the end. accountants' fraud, homebuyers' association. PLURAL POSSESSIVE, hence "'" at the end.
ReplyDelete